Questioning the Consequences of Montana Lawmaker’s Words and Their Unusual Notoriety

53

In Montana, Zooey Zephyr, a transgender lawmaker was quickly punished for what she said. She had accused her opponent of having ‘blood’ on their hands – something that many other politicians have said without getting in trouble.

Recently, some people in positions of power like governors, congresspeople and city council members, have blamed their fellow officials for causing death with the exact same words. These deaths were linked to things like immigration rules and gun regulations.

On Thursday, lawmaker Zephyr faced something that others didn’t — a punishment imposed by Montana Republicans due to her speaking out against a ban on gender-affirming care. They put her in legislative exile, which kept her away from the state House floor. This was all one week after she declared that if this ban passed, it would have “blood on its hands.”

Lou Barletta, a Republican former Congressman from Pennsylvania, brought up an idea of controversy about something for 2021. He expressed that he has never had anyone make a big deal out of it.

In response to Zephyr’s opinion, Montana Republicans said that she took the political debate too far. Political arguments between politicians are very common in the USA, especially in statehouses where people speak out about hot topics like abortion and gun laws, with some even accusing one another of having “blood on their hands”.

Zephyr went too far with her remarks, but an expert on American politics believes this was an exaggeration. Even though the Republican government in Montana controlled what happened, they decided to punish Zephyr for speaking out. This is an example of how more and more governments are not allowing people to express their opinions freely.

Jennifer Mercieca, a professor at Texas A&M University explained that when people say “there’s blood on your hands”, they are actually saying there are serious consequences to the decisions you make. Even though it might sound harsh, it’s not meant to be an insult. It’s just a polite way of warning you about the bad things that can happen if you do certain things.

This all started in April this year when Zephyr said something angry about a prayer that was being said before the start of an official meeting. She said, “I wish that you would feel like you were carrying blood on your hands even when bowing your heads in prayer.” This made the people who were involved very mad as they thought what she said was very rude and dismissive.

In an interview, Zephyr said that when she had her turn to speak at the House on Wednesday, the majority leader disagreed but she didn’t expect it would become a big problem. However, people stopped listening to how bad this bill could be for people.

Studies have shown that transgender young people are more likely to think about suicide or even try it if they don’t get access to medical care that supports them based on their gender.

The person, who identified as Zephyr, a Democrat lawmaker with only one term under her belt, said that if someone votes for the bill being put forward, they are helping to cause people’s deaths. Other members of both political parties agree with this statement.

In 2021 in Texas when Democrats refused to be present to vote on a law concerning voting they were criticized by Governor Greg Abbott from the Republican Party. He said that their absence from the session caused them to have ‘blood on their hands’ due to not completing their job and allowing the crime bill to pass or fail.

When Alabama tried to stop letting people carry hidden guns last year, Democrat Representative Merika Coleman said something serious to other Members of Congress. She warned them that if this law passes, some of them would not be able to escape the guilt or responsibility for any violence with a gun that happens afterwards.

Grant Cramer, a high school freshman in Colorado whose friend had been shot, said to four Democratic politicians that they were responsible for the death. The chairman of the committee (which was deciding on a ban on semiautomatic firearms) kindly told Grant not to blame them.

“I expected you to ask my opinion and the opinions of all 12 others,” Rep. Mike Weissman said. “It’s important for everyone to have their say, and I think that would be right.”

In Florida, Senator Jason Pizzo (a Democrat) heard people say “blood on hands” many times during debates. Once, he even cursed at a person testifying in front of the state agency.

Kathleen Passidomo (a Republican Senate President) wasn’t sure if it was appropriate for someone to use this phrase during debates. She said it’s not a good thing to do but she’s still heard it from other people and let them continue debating.

___

A reporter named Weber was sending information from Austin, Texas. To help him, other people from four different places also added their reports – Brendan Farrington from Tallahassee, Florida; Kim Chandler from Montgomery, Alabama; Marc Levy from Harrisburg, Pennsylvania; and Jesse Bedayn from Denver.