Democracy’s Pillar Under Threat in the UK: The Erosion of Protest Rights

In the United Kingdom, peaceful protests are facing unprecedented threats, challenging a fundamental aspect of democratic society. A retiree is potentially facing two years in prison merely for displaying a sign outside a courthouse, which reminded jurors of their right to acquit. Similarly, an engineer received a three-year sentence for suspending a ‘Just Stop Oil’ banner from a bridge. Numerous individuals have been detained for simply walking slowly down streets, a peaceful form of protest.

These instances are not isolated, but rather part of a broader pattern involving hundreds of environmental activists who have been arrested in the UK. The enforcement of stringent new laws has significantly limited the traditional right to protest. While the Conservative government defends these measures as necessary to prevent radical activists from disrupting the economy and daily life, opponents argue that these actions are eroding civil liberties with inadequate oversight from legislative bodies and insufficient judicial protection. The broad arrest of non-violent protesters and the government’s labeling of environmental activists as extremists signal a troubling shift in the framework of a liberal democracy.

Jonathon Porritt, an environmentalist and ex-director of Friends of the Earth, emphasized the importance of legitimate protest in maintaining a safe and civilized society. He accused the government of deliberately suppressing lawful protest using every available means.

A Patchwork of Democracy in Jeopardy

The UK’s longstanding democratic traditions, including the Magna Carta, an age-old Parliament, and an independent judiciary, are rooted in an unwritten constitution comprising laws, conventions, and judicial decisions developed over centuries. Andrew Blick, author and political scientist at King’s College London, highlighted the reliance of the British system on government self-restraint. However, recent actions by Prime Ministers Boris Johnson and Rishi Sunak have strained these democratic foundations, raising concerns about the system’s resilience.

Targeting Protesters

Environmental activists, who employ various attention-grabbing methods to highlight climate change dangers, are increasingly seen as the canaries in the coal mine for protest rights. The government’s response to these protests has been to enact laws that severely limit the scope of peaceful protest. Legal amendments in 2022 introduced a “public nuisance” offense with potential ten-year prison sentences, and further police powers to limit disruptive protests. The 2023 Public Order Act expanded these restrictions, criminalizing the obstruction of key infrastructure and introducing hefty penalties.

Despite government assurances of protecting public interests, there’s growing anxiety about the implications of these laws on the fundamental right to protest. The prompt arrest of protesters for minor infractions and the imposition of severe sentences have drawn international criticism. United Nations officials have condemned the UK’s anti-protest laws as an attack on peaceful assembly rights.

The Brexit Factor

Many experts link the UK’s increasingly authoritarian stance towards protesters to the broader political shift following Brexit. The 2016 referendum, championed by populist rhetoric, led to significant power shifts and tested the limits of the UK’s unwritten constitution. Johnson’s tenure as prime minister saw multiple constitutional challenges, including the unlawful suspension of Parliament and personal scandals.

Current Prime Minister Sunak’s attempts to override judicial decisions, like the Supreme Court’s ruling against sending asylum-seekers to Rwanda, further exemplify the government’s willingness to challenge democratic norms.

A Democracy in Need of Reform?

The UK’s parliamentary system, traditionally a check on executive power, has been less effective recently due to reduced legislative scrutiny and a dominant Conservative majority. The House of Lords, despite its lack of democratic legitimacy, has attempted to mitigate some of these issues, but its capacity is limited.

The debate over the UK’s democratic deficit has intensified post-Brexit, with calls for constitutional reform, including proposals for a written constitution. Meanwhile, protesters maintain their efforts, viewing their actions as vital not only for environmental causes but also for preserving democratic freedoms.

Sue Parfitt, an 81-year-old Anglican priest and member of Christian Climate Action, embodies this spirit. Despite numerous arrests and the potential risk of imprisonment, she remains committed to safeguarding the right to protest.

This report, part of a series by the Pulitzer Center for Crisis Reporting, delves into the ongoing challenges to democracy in Europe.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about UK Protest Rights

More about UK Protest Rights

• The Guardian – UK Protest Rights
• Pulitzer Center – Threats to Democracy in Europe
• BBC News – Brexit and UK Democracy
• United Nations – Climate Change and Human Rights