Pope Initiates Major Vatican Assembly Amidst Growing Tensions Over His Reform Initiatives

19

Pope Francis commenced a significant assembly focused on the future trajectory of the Catholic Church this Wednesday. While progressive factions are optimistic that the assembly will herald increased roles for women in church leadership, conservative elements caution that fundamental church teachings—from issues like homosexuality to ecclesiastical authority—are potentially jeopardized.

The Pope conducted a dignified Mass in St. Peter’s Square to officially inaugurate the assembly. Clergy from across the globe were present at the altar, preceding a diverse array of ordinary Catholic laity. The inclusion of laypeople in this assembly signals a pivotal transformation in the Catholic Church’s dynamics.

This particular Vatican gathering—known as a synod—has sparked an unparalleled level of anticipation, excitement, and apprehension. Although it won’t yield any binding resolutions and is merely the initial phase of a two-year process, the meeting has intensified the perennial ideological divide within the church and serves as a crucial juncture for Pope Francis’s reformative aspirations.

Before the event even began, the assembly had already achieved a historic status. Pope Francis has permitted women and laypeople to vote in the creation of any concluding documents alongside bishops. Although they constitute fewer than 25% of the 365 voting participants, this inclusion represents a drastic departure from a previously hierarchy-centric Synod of Bishops. This shift mirrors Francis’s conviction that the church should prioritize its congregation over its clergy.

Additional Coverage

• Pope Indicates Potential Blessings for Same-Sex Unions, Countering Five Conservative Cardinals
• Significance of Women’s Voices Heightened as Pope Prepares to Initiate Vatican Assembly on Church’s Future
• Pope Francis Appoints 21 New Cardinals to Assist in Church Reforms and Secure His Legacy

JoAnn Lopez, a lay minister of Indian origin who facilitated consultations in the two years leading up to the assembly, remarked, “This represents a monumental change. For the first time, women are experiencing a distinctively different level of participation, particularly in voting and decision-making processes.”

The assembly will consider proposals for concrete actions to advance women into decision-making roles within the church, possibly as deacons. Also on the agenda is an evaluation of means to more inclusively welcome LGBTQ+ members and others who have been sidelined by the church, in addition to instituting new mechanisms for holding bishops accountable to prevent abuses.

Women have persistently criticized their secondary status within the church, despite being responsible for the majority of church-related activities—ranging from education to healthcare and the transference of faith to future generations. They seek a more significant role in church governance, advocating for voting rights at Vatican synods, the right to deliver sermons during Mass, and eligibility for ordination as priests or deacons.

Though some women have attained notable positions in both the Vatican and local churches worldwide, the governance of the church remains predominantly male.

Before the Mass began, proponents of ordaining women unfurled a sizable purple banner proclaiming, “Ordain Women.”

Lopez and other women are particularly enthused about the possibility that the synod might pave the way for the ordination of women as deacons, a ministry presently restricted to men. Advocates for female deacons assert that women served in such roles in the early church and that reinstating this ministry would both benefit the church and acknowledge the unique contributions of women.

While Pope Francis has convened research commissions to investigate the matter, he has refrained from instituting any changes thus far. He has also excluded from consideration the debate on female priests.

Miriam Duignan, from the advocacy group Women’s Ordination Worldwide, stated that proponents desire the synod to acknowledge that women served as ministers in the early church and should be reinstated accordingly.

This assembly’s potential to effect genuine change on previously taboo subjects has invigorated many progressive Catholics and women, while simultaneously alarming conservatives. Critics, particularly those in the U.S., have written books, organized conferences, and utilized social media platforms to argue that Francis’s reforms are engendering doctrinal confusion and undermining the church’s core teachings.

On the eve of the assembly, American Cardinal Raymond Burke issued a scathing critique of Francis’s concept of “synodality” and his broader reformative goals, contending that the term “synodal” lacks clarity and that its underlying philosophy of decentralizing authority imperils the church’s very identity.

Cardinal Robert Sarah, a colleague of Burke’s who has also openly challenged Pope Francis, was among those in attendance.

In a public exchange of letters released on Monday, Pope Francis refrained from directly addressing the Cardinals’ concerns, suggesting that they should not fear the questions raised by a world in flux. In relation to the specific issue of blessings for same-sex unions, the Pope indicated that such blessings could be permissible provided they are not conflated with sacramental marriage.

---

Contributions to this report were made by Big Big News journalist Trisha Thomas.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Vatican assembly

More about Vatican assembly

• Pope Francis’s Reform Agenda
• What is a Synod in the Catholic Church?
• The Role of Women in the Catholic Church
• LGBTQ+ Inclusion in Catholic Doctrine
• Vatican Assemblies and Ecclesiastical Authority
• Conservative Response to Pope Francis’s Reforms
• Cardinal Raymond Burke’s Views on the Synod