Is Israel’s Military Action in Gaza an Invasion? The Army’s Ambiguity Raises Questions Even as Objectives Remain Defined

17

In the past week, Israeli military forces have progressively penetrated further into Gaza, initiating this campaign in retaliation to an Oct. 7 incursion by the Islamic militant organization, Hamas.

The Israeli military’s involvement has broadened to include naval, air, and ground units. According to official statements, they have eliminated numerous militants and compromised Hamas’ extensive tunnel infrastructure. Soldiers have also commandeered vacant Palestinian residences for strategic purposes.

Despite the escalation of military activities each day, the Israeli army refrains from describing the operation as an invasion.

This nuanced language is more than a trivial matter of word choice; it appears to be a calculated tactic designed to disorient its adversary and retain tactical flexibility in an evolving conflict.

A Detailed Examination of Israeli Activities in Gaza

What Constitutes an Invasion?

By traditional standards, Israel’s military actions bear the hallmarks of an invasion.

Israeli ground troops have been active within enemy borders since the previous Friday, backed by various military assets like tanks, artillery, infantry, bulldozers, and special forces, all supported by air power.

The Israeli military has not disclosed specific information about the scope or scale of its deployment. Nonetheless, official announcements suggest a growing number of troops are being committed to the effort.

Conversely, Palestinian authorities have employed markedly stronger language, labeling Israel’s sustained aerial assault as a “massacre” and “genocide.” According to Gaza’s Health Ministry, governed by Hamas, the campaign has resulted in over 8,000 Palestinian deaths and significant infrastructural damage.

The Military’s Terminology

The Israeli army eschews the term “invasion,” opting instead for descriptors like “raids” and “operations.”

This terminology highlights the fluidity of the situation. The Israeli army seems to be refraining, at least for now, from committing overwhelming ground forces in an attempt to defeat Hamas.

This approach seems aimed at creating uncertainty within Hamas while preserving flexibility for future military activities. Israel has explicitly stated its intention to sustain its military presence in Gaza for an extended period.

Over the past weekend, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared the operation had entered a new phase. Gallant indicated, “We have transitioned into a new chapter of the conflict. The ground in Gaza is unstable. The operation will persist until a new order is established.”

During a visit to the troops on Tuesday, Gallant further elaborated, stating, “We are deploying troops extensively into the depths of Gaza.”

The Objectives Defined

Israel has outlined two primary goals: the safe return of all hostages and the complete dismantling of Hamas, which is heavily armed and enjoys considerable public support.

Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari, Israel’s chief military spokesperson, regularly alludes to a meticulous strategy to accomplish these objectives, even though he refrains from terming it an “invasion.” He declared on Tuesday, “Our offensive undertakings will persist and escalate in accordance with our planned approach.”

Amir Avivi, a retired general and former deputy commander of the Israeli army’s Gaza division, acknowledges that the use of vague terms is deliberate. “The goal is to keep the enemy in the dark about our plans,” he stated.

Avivi, who currently leads the Israel Defense and Security Forum, a consortium of hawkish retired military officers, clarified that comprehensive measures will be required to achieve Israel’s objectives.

“The only viable strategy involves occupying the entire Gaza Strip and dedicating many months to neutralize all capabilities,” he said. “The specific terminology employed by the army is inconsequential in this context.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Israeli military ambiguity in Gaza

More about Israeli military ambiguity in Gaza

• Israeli Defense Ministry Statements
• Gaza Health Ministry Reports
• Analysis on Military Terminology
• Overview of Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
• Statements from International Observers
• Israel Defense and Security Forum Publications