The Israeli-Hamas Conflict Exposes Divisions within the Republican Party on Isolationism

25

Nikki Haley has publicly declared her unwavering support for Israel, vowing to severely undermine the Iranian economy. She has also advocated for continued financial aid for Ukraine amidst its struggle against Russian aggression. Addressing Republican primary voters in New Hampshire, she acknowledged the global landscape as perilous, stating, “The situation will likely deteriorate before it stabilizes.”

Contrastingly, less than a day later, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis articulated a divergent perspective. Speaking to New Hampshire’s business community, he suggested that U.S. support for Ukraine should be paused until a definitive strategy is in place. DeSantis shifted the focus to what he perceives as a more immediate threat—foreign nationals at the U.S.-Mexico border. Regarding the conflict between Israel and Hamas, he said the U.S. may not need to take extensive military actions, although some form of traditional support could be necessary.

Complex Foreign Policy Debates Amidst Republican Candidates

Republican contenders for the White House are presenting disparate views on pressing foreign policy issues. What was initially a campaign focused predominantly on domestic affairs is now confronted with an escalating global crisis. This schism within the party threatens to dilute the GOP’s unified criticism of President Joe Biden’s foreign policy stewardship.

Republican primary voters in New Hampshire, who have recently inundated their presidential hopefuls with questions about international relations, are evidently seeking more coherent policy positions. Tom Rath, a former New Hampshire Attorney General, encapsulated this sentiment, lamenting the absence of a rational voice in the current international turmoil.

Changing Tides of Republican Foreign Policy

This conflict serves as a glaring reminder of how the Republican Party has evolved. It has shifted from its previous stances, embodied by figures like George W. Bush, who recently described himself as a “hard-liner” regarding foreign policy. Under Donald Trump’s tenure, the party has significantly retreated from its traditional commitment to an assertive role in global affairs. A poll conducted during last year’s midterm elections revealed that 56% of Republican voters felt that the U.S. should be less involved in international matters.

Nikki Haley stands as a bastion of the GOP’s former assertive international stance, calling for a resolute action against entities hostile to Israel, including Hamas and Iran. Conversely, DeSantis, along with entrepreneur Vivek Ramaswamy and backed by conservative commentator Tucker Carlson, espouses a more restrained “America First” ideology.

Inconsistent Messaging Adds to the Confusion

Donald Trump has muddled the conversation with inconsistent declarations, exacerbated by personal grievances. While he criticized Israeli leaders for what he considered inadequate preparedness for the Hamas incursion, his team later clarified his historical support for Israel.

Discontent within the Republican Base

Some Republican primary voters are expressing dissatisfaction with their options for presidential candidates. Michele Woonton, a retired nurse who attended a DeSantis event, indicated that neither Biden nor Trump provides the strong leadership she desires. Bruce Wilson, a 76-year-old Army veteran, voiced a wish for the Republican Party to return to its historical strength in foreign policy.

Dave Lundgren, a Republican state representative who endorses DeSantis, also expressed concerns over the party’s increasingly isolationist tendencies. He advocated for more assertive U.S. actions, potentially involving special forces, in response to the attacks on Israel by Hamas.

---

Contributions for this report were made by Jill Colvin of Big Big News in New York and Emily Swanson, AP’s polling director in Washington.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Republican Party’s Foreign Policy Divide

More about Republican Party’s Foreign Policy Divide

• Understanding the Israeli-Hamas Conflict
• The Evolution of Republican Foreign Policy
• Nikki Haley’s Stance on Global Issues
• Ron DeSantis on U.S. Foreign Policy
• Donald Trump’s Impact on the GOP
• Voter Sentiments on Foreign Policy
• U.S. Isolationism: A Historical Overview
• President Joe Biden’s Foreign Policy Approach
• Republican Ideological Shifts
• 2024 Presidential Election: GOP Hopefuls