As the Endangered Species Act turns 50, those who first enforced it reflect on its mixed legacy

44

As the 50th anniversary of the Endangered Species Act approaches, those who were at the forefront of its enforcement reflect on its complex legacy. On December 28, 1973, President Richard Nixon signed this pivotal legislation, emphasizing the importance of preserving the diverse animal life that graced the United States. At the time of its inception, the Act garnered widespread bipartisan support, entrusting the federal government with the task of safeguarding every endangered plant and animal in the country.

The Act’s broad scope inevitably led to controversy, particularly because it allowed species to be classified as endangered without considering the economic ramifications. This sparked a clash between two fundamental American values: the desire to protect the nation’s natural resources and the belief in the supremacy of capitalism and private property rights.

The Endangered Species Act was part of a wave of environmental legislation passed in the mid-1960s, which included the Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act, Wilderness Act, and National Wild and Scenic Rivers Act. Together, this legislation constituted the most comprehensive environmental protection measures in the world.

During this era, there was a widespread commitment to addressing environmental damage caused by unchecked greed, which had resulted in pollution of the air and water, as well as the near-extinction of iconic American species like the bison and the bald eagle. The Act initially received accolades for its role in the recovery of these national symbols. However, when lesser-known species obstructed development, opinions shifted.

A group of young biologists in Washington, known as the first Office of Endangered Species, faced the daunting task of navigating this challenging terrain.

Jim Williams, an ichthyologist, was among the early members of this team. He demonstrated an unconventional approach when he advocated for listing the snail darter, a tiny fish that existed only in one stretch of the Little Tennessee River, which the Tennessee Valley Authority planned to dam. Despite resistance, Williams listed the snail darter, preserving the Act but diminishing its initial support. The question of whether the government should protect all species from extinction or where to draw the line became a contentious issue.

In an attempt to prioritize species for listing, administrators created a system that frequently changed, frustrating biologists. In response, they crafted a satirical memorandum listing criteria that ranged from “things that are warm and fluffy” to “things difficult to step on.” Williams and his colleagues relied on allies in the nonprofit sector to support their conservation efforts.

Ken Dodd, a herpetologist, joined the Office of Endangered Species and frequently clashed with administrators. He followed the science without regard for potential inconveniences, challenging companies like Purina pet food and Monsanto. Dodd’s termination in 1979 resulted from a letter he wrote to a restaurant owner about serving rattlesnake meat in violation of the law. Public outcry, expressed through T-shirts that read “Save Ken Dodd and Rattlesnakes,” helped reinstate him.

Ron Nowak, who specialized in wolves and panthers, testified against his own agency in the mid-1980s when it sought to open a hunting season for gray wolves in Minnesota. He believed such a move would be illegal and joined conservation groups in legal battles, ultimately preventing the hunting season. Although his supervisors wanted to fire him, they were deterred by the fear of creating another martyr like Dodd. Nowak’s unit was eventually dismantled, and he was reassigned.

LaVerne Smith, a botanist, continued her work with the endangered species program, even as the office underwent reorganizations. She played a critical role in the recovery of the California condor, which had dwindled to 23 individuals by 1982. Smith later led the listing for the polar bear, marking the first time an animal was listed as endangered due to climate change. She emphasized the need for quicker decisions to address the rapidly evolving threat.

Marc Imlay, a malacologist, focused on freshwater mussels, one of the most endangered groups in the country. He employed unconventional methods, sometimes working secretly to protect these species. Imlay found solutions that balanced development with conservation, often collaborating with developers to protect natural areas while allowing housing construction.

John Spinks, an early chief of the Office of Endangered Species, managed a group of passionate biologists who were dedicated to their work. He occasionally witnessed his staff circumventing bureaucratic obstacles, and one of his memorandums, leaked to The Washington Post, exposed roadblocks hindering species listings. This leak brought attention to the obstructionist practices of the solicitor’s office.

In retrospect, these individuals and their colleagues at the Office of Endangered Species demonstrated unwavering dedication to preserving endangered species and protecting the environment, often at great personal and professional cost. Their collective efforts marked a unique period in conservation history, characterized by a commitment to safeguarding the natural world.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Endangered Species Act

More about Endangered Species Act

• Endangered Species Act (ESA) Overview
• The Endangered Species Act at 50: A Wild Success
• History of the Endangered Species Act
• Key Figures in ESA Conservation
• Species Recovery Success Stories
• Challenges and Controversies of the ESA
• Climate Change and the ESA
• Impact of the ESA on Wildlife Conservation