The Paradox of Indoor Farming: Why Do New Ventures Emerge Amidst Industry Failures?

by Ethan Kim
Indoor Farming

In a sprawling greenhouse roughly an hour from Dallas, workers garbed in hairnets and gloves meticulously insert seedlings of lettuce and various leafy greens into miniature plastic receptacles, which accumulate in towering stacks. Within a matter of weeks, these vegetables will attain maturity, be harvested, packaged, and distributed to local stores, all within a 48-hour time frame.

This operation belongs to Eden Green Technology, a rising player in the domain of indoor agriculture. The firm currently manages two greenhouses and is in the process of establishing two additional facilities at its Cleburne campus. The objective of these indoor operations is dual-fold: to provide a buffer against the impacts of climate change on food security and to do so in a manner that economizes water and land usage.

However, the longevity and efficacy of this business model remain open questions. Despite some organizations faltering in their attempts to make indoor farming profitable—case in point, New Jersey’s AeroFarms and Kentucky’s AppHarvest filed for bankruptcy restructuring, while Detroit-based Planted Detroit shuttered its operations citing financial strains—others are forging ahead. For instance, California’s Plenty Unlimited has initiated construction of a $300 million facility, and retail giant Kroger is extending its range of vertically farmed produce.

Jacob Portillo, an agricultural specialist at Eden Green, remains undeterred by the industry’s turbulent dynamics. “In any business sector, there will be both triumphs and setbacks,” he observes. “But I am optimistic that those prioritizing sustainability will eventually gain the upper hand.”

Indoor farming is an umbrella term encompassing an array of techniques collectively known as “controlled environment agriculture.” Among these are vertical farming, which relies heavily on artificial lighting and hydroponic systems, and large-scale greenhouses that may also incorporate robotic automation for certain agricultural processes.

Proponents argue that indoor farming addresses several ecological concerns by reducing water and land requirements and by situating food production closer to consumer locales. However, critics question the environmental trade-offs, particularly the reliance on energy-intensive artificial lighting, which they argue could undermine profitability.

Tom Kimmerer, a plant physiologist and academic, has followed the industry with a critical eye. His initial assessment of indoor farms, especially those dependent on artificial lighting, was rather skeptical due to the high operational costs. Some companies are attempting to offset these expenses through renewable energy sources like solar power.

However, Kimmerer suggests that more practical and eco-friendly methods to lengthen the growing season are available, which involve outdoor farming. For example, Elmwood Stock Farm in Kentucky utilizes high tunnels or hoop houses, structures that offer partial outdoor exposure while still providing shelter for crops.

Investments in indoor farming could arguably be reallocated to pragmatic technologies for conventional farmers, such as advanced robotic systems for weed control, or to initiatives aimed at promoting regenerative agricultural practices.

The other challenge for indoor farms is pest management. Hannah Burrack, an ecologist specializing in pest control at Michigan State University, points out that an environment optimized for plant growth may also be ideal for pests, necessitating rigorous monitoring and intervention.

Companies like Eden Green counter this criticism by highlighting their strict hygiene standards, claiming that their controlled environments actually require fewer pesticides than traditional outdoor farming.

Evan Lucas, an associate professor at Northern Michigan University, believes the industry’s current volatility is a natural part of its evolution. According to Lucas, the rapid pace at which companies are entering this space may contribute to scalability issues, particularly if the infrastructure is not specifically designed for indoor agricultural needs.

Financial stakeholders offer varied opinions on the industry’s prospects. While Eden Green and Plenty assert their respective approaches have profitability potential, Curt Covington of AgAmerica Lending expresses skepticism, noting the high capital costs as a significant barrier to sustained profitability.

In summary, while the indoor farming industry experiences both expansions and contractions, its ultimate viability remains a subject of ongoing debate. Factors such as energy costs, pest management, and the efficacy of alternative farming practices will continue to shape the sector’s trajectory.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Indoor Farming

What is the main subject of the article?

The main subject of the article is the indoor farming industry. It delves into the complexities, challenges, and opportunities facing businesses in this sector, particularly focusing on sustainability and profitability.

Why are new indoor farms being built despite others shutting down?

New indoor farms are being constructed on the premise of achieving year-round crop production with fewer resources like water and land. These farms are also seeking to mitigate the risks posed by climate change. Despite some companies failing, others see opportunities for profitability and sustainability.

What are the benefits of indoor farming according to advocates?

Advocates argue that indoor farming uses less water and land, enables local food production thus reducing transportation costs, and offers a controlled environment that can protect crops from extreme weather conditions. Many also claim reduced pesticide use.

What concerns do skeptics have about indoor farming?

Skeptics primarily question the energy requirements for indoor farming, especially those operations that rely heavily on artificial light. The high energy costs are seen as a potential barrier to profitability.

What alternative solutions to indoor farming are discussed?

Tom Kimmerer, a plant physiologist, suggests that there are more practical outdoor farming solutions such as high tunnels or hoop houses. He also mentions the potential for outdoor farmers to use advanced technology like weed-zapping robots and regenerative practices.

How do indoor farms manage pest problems?

Indoor farming companies emphasize stringent hygiene standards. For example, Eden Green maintains “laboratory conditions” and workers are trained to monitor greenhouses closely to catch any pests immediately. The environment also typically requires fewer pesticides than traditional farming.

What are the challenges for scaling indoor farming?

Scaling challenges can include high energy costs, the capital-intensive nature of the operations, and potential issues with pest management. Some companies may also struggle to adapt spaces that were not originally designed for indoor farming.

Are there any significant investments in the indoor farming industry?

Yes, notable investments have been made, such as Walmart participating in a $400 million round for Plenty Unlimited. However, the industry also has skeptics who question the long-term viability and profitability of these operations.

What impact could partnerships with big retailers have on the indoor farming industry?

Partnerships with large retailers like Walmart could potentially provide the capital and scale needed to make indoor farming more profitable. These collaborations could also serve as a form of socially conscious venture capital.

More about Indoor Farming

You may also like


Linda Carter September 17, 2023 - 8:39 pm

Honestly, so many companies jumping in so fast. No wonder some are failing. They need to start slow and learn the ropes first. Scaling too quickly is a recipe for disaster in any biz.

Sarah Williams September 18, 2023 - 1:52 am

So it’s not just me thinkin’ the energy costs could be a deal-breaker? If you need a sun’s worth of energy in bulbs, how’s that sustainable?

Greg Miller September 18, 2023 - 4:49 am

I’m all for sustainability, but the article made me realize that its not just a one-size-fits-all. There are challenges in every approach. Also, if it was that easy everyone would be doing it right?

Jake Roberts September 18, 2023 - 1:05 pm

Did anyone else catch the part about pests? The fact that you could be creating a paradise for bugs while growing your lettuce is kinda funny and scary at the same time.

Timothy Chang September 18, 2023 - 2:18 pm

Elmwood Stock Farm sounds interesting. Love the idea of extending the outdoor growing season without the need for high-tech, expensive setups. Sometimes simple is better.

Karen Smith September 18, 2023 - 2:41 pm

Investments from Walmart and other big names could be game changers. But they also need to keep it real; not just about the profits but the planet too.

Mike Johnson September 18, 2023 - 4:29 pm

Wow, didn’t know that indoor farming was such a mixed bag. Seems like some people are betting big while others are going belly up. Crazy times huh?


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News