The Federal Trade Commission’s Antitrust Litigation Against Amazon is Expected to be a Lengthy and Complex Endeavor

by Ryan Lee
FTC Antitrust Lawsuit Against Amazon

As Amazon prepares for one of its most significant annual sales events—Prime Day—it faces a pending lawsuit accusing the company of restricting sellers from offering their products at more competitive prices on other platforms.

This antitrust suit, initiated by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), marks the agency’s boldest action yet to curtail Amazon’s market influence, a company now virtually synonymous with e-commerce and rapid delivery services.

FTC Chair Lina Khan, appointed by President Joe Biden, has been unreserved in her willingness to challenge America’s largest corporations by pushing the boundaries of antitrust legislation. This aggressive strategy has not been without setbacks, such as the FTC’s failed attempts to prevent Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision Blizzard and Meta’s purchase of virtual reality start-up Within Unlimited. These setbacks are currently under appeal.

The lawsuit against Amazon is particularly significant for Khan, who previously examined the company in a seminal paper, “Amazon’s Antitrust Paradox,” written during her time at Yale Law School. In her paper, Khan argued that the conventional focus on price effects in antitrust evaluations is outdated, advocating for a broader examination of market impact.

Two years ago, after her appointment to lead the FTC, Amazon unsuccessfully tried to disqualify her from investigations into the company, claiming she held biases. Now, her agency is tasked with demonstrating in court that Amazon both holds monopoly power and uses it to stifle market competition.

“A successful outcome will revitalize competition and result in lower prices, better quality, and increased variety for consumers,” Khan recently stated in a call with the media.

A conclusive verdict on the Amazon lawsuit may take years and could be influenced by a change in administration, a judge’s dismissal, or a settlement similar to Amazon’s agreement with European authorities last year. The FTC’s case also faces several challenges, such as defining which market segment Amazon purportedly monopolizes.

In its 172-page federal complaint, the FTC outlines Amazon’s coercive practices with sellers, asserting the company wields monopoly power in specific online market sectors—not the entire U.S. e-commerce market, where Amazon controls an estimated 40%.

Amazon’s General Counsel, David Zapolsky, responded by accusing the FTC of manipulating market definitions. He argued that Amazon is merely one component of a robust retail environment, highlighting that over 80% of retail purchases still occur in physical stores.

The online retail landscape has also seen the emergence of formidable competitors like Walmart, Shein, and Temu from China, as well as platforms such as Etsy and Shopify that empower small businesses.

In addition to market definition complexities, the FTC’s complaint zeroes in on Amazon’s increasing fees for third-party sellers and the subsequent impact on consumers. It alleges that Amazon enforces punitive measures against sellers who offer better prices elsewhere online.

Legal experts note that the paucity of recent monopolization cases could make the FTC’s case against Amazon challenging. Maurice Stucke, a law professor at the University of Tennessee and former senior advisor at the FTC, warned that even if the FTC prevails, market conditions could enable Amazon to sustain its dominant position without the conduct currently under scrutiny.

Khan has refrained from commenting on whether the FTC aims to dismantle Amazon but stated the immediate goal is to establish liability. However, the lawsuit does mention the potential for “structural relief,” indicating that the agency may later request court-ordered changes to Amazon’s business practices.

Sean Sullivan, a law professor at the University of Iowa, noted that few monopolization cases have resulted in court-mandated company divestitures. Judges, he says, are cautious, understanding that any mistake could have widespread economic repercussions.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about FTC Antitrust Lawsuit Against Amazon

What is the central focus of the Federal Trade Commission’s lawsuit against Amazon?

The central focus of the lawsuit is to investigate Amazon for alleged antitrust violations. The FTC aims to prove that Amazon has a monopoly in certain online market sectors and uses its power to stifle competition, particularly by restricting sellers from offering their products at lower prices on other platforms.

Who is leading the FTC’s efforts in this case?

Lina Khan, Chair of the Federal Trade Commission, is spearheading the agency’s efforts in this case. She has been a vocal critic of Amazon’s market dominance and has pushed for a more expansive interpretation of antitrust law.

What significant challenges does the FTC face in this lawsuit?

The FTC faces several challenges, including defining the specific market segment that Amazon purportedly monopolizes. The agency also needs to navigate the complexities of antitrust law and demonstrate how Amazon’s conduct negatively affects both sellers and consumers.

What role does Lina Khan’s academic work play in the case?

Lina Khan’s prior academic work, particularly her paper “Amazon’s Antitrust Paradox,” has influenced the FTC’s approach to this case. In her paper, Khan criticized the traditional focus on price effects in antitrust cases and called for a broader understanding of market impact.

Has Amazon responded to the lawsuit?

Yes, Amazon’s General Counsel, David Zapolsky, responded by accusing the FTC of manipulating market definitions to make Amazon appear as a monopoly. He emphasized that Amazon is just one part of a large and competitive retail market.

Are there other legal cases against Amazon for similar issues?

Yes, a similar lawsuit was filed last year by the state of California and is scheduled to go to trial in 2026. The District of Columbia also attempted to sue Amazon on similar grounds, but that lawsuit was dismissed by a federal judge.

What could be the potential outcomes if the FTC wins the lawsuit?

If the FTC wins, it could lead to “structural relief,” meaning the agency could ask the court to mandate changes to how Amazon operates. This could revitalize competition and potentially lead to lower prices, better quality, and greater variety for consumers.

Are there any precedents for this kind of antitrust lawsuit?

There are few recent precedents involving monopolization cases, making this lawsuit particularly challenging. It is one of the most significant U.S. antitrust trials since the Department of Justice’s case against Google and the cases against Microsoft decades ago.

Could political changes affect the outcome of the lawsuit?

Yes, the lawsuit could be influenced by changes in political administration. A new administration could choose to drop the lawsuit, or a judge could dismiss the case.

What is the timeline for the lawsuit’s conclusion?

A definitive conclusion may take years to reach. Factors such as a change in administration, judge’s decisions, or potential settlements could influence the timeline.

More about FTC Antitrust Lawsuit Against Amazon

You may also like


EmilyR October 15, 2023 - 11:05 pm

Interesting to see how politics might play a role here. what if a new admin comes in and just drops the case? Would be a waste of all this effort.

finance_wiz October 15, 2023 - 11:57 pm

If Khan pulls this off, it’s going to be a game changer for antitrust law. watch this space, folks!

Alex_S October 16, 2023 - 1:50 am

Comprehensive but kinda overwhelming. There’s so much here to unpack. Makes you wonder if all this will even make a difference a few years from now.

VickyP October 16, 2023 - 2:43 am

Love the detailed look into the FTC’s case but also the challenges they face. However, if the FTC wins what happens next? Big changes or just a slap on the wrist for Amazon?

John D. October 16, 2023 - 9:16 am

Wow, this is a pretty comprehensive article on the FTC’s case against Amazon. Lina Khan seems to be shaking things up. She’s been after Amazon for a while now, hasn’t she?

TechGuru October 16, 2023 - 12:35 pm

Amazon’s response is kinda intriguing. They do have a point, the retail market is massive and Amazon’s just a part. Does the FTC really think they can gerrymander Amazon into a monopoly?

mike_87 October 16, 2023 - 3:03 pm

So many legal hurdles. idk, but Amazon is like a huge monster in retail, not sure how the FTC plans to tame it.

Sara_M October 16, 2023 - 5:22 pm

Impressive depth! But let’s be real, what are the chances that Amazon actually loses? Seems like the odds are stacked against the FTC.


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News