Residents of Gaza Confront Grim Dilemma: Remain Under Bombardment or Risk Displacement Amid Airstrikes?

by Chloe Baker
Gaza Dilemma

In the desolate pathways of the Jabaliya refugee camp in the northern part of Gaza, Naji Jamal found himself paralyzed by a dire choice.

Should he comply with the Israeli military’s directive urging all Palestinians to vacate the area, embarking on a perilous journey to southern Gaza with the certainty of displacement awaiting him? Alternatively, should he remain in his multi-level residential building, now declared a strike zone by the Israeli military, as a potential Israeli ground invasion looms?

“The question is existential in nature, yet lacks a definitive answer,” said Jamal, a 34-year-old healthcare worker. “There is no sanctuary, no area free from bombardment and siege; nowhere to run.”

Amid an escalating conflict marked by Hamas’ deadly assault that claimed over 1,300 Israeli lives, the Israeli military issued an unprecedented ultimatum to civilians in northern Gaza and Gaza City, including Jamal and 1.1 million others. They were given 24 hours to decide, marking the sixth day of Israeli aerial bombardments.

As the ultimatum countdown progressed, a significant force of Israeli army reservists began assembling near Gaza’s northern border. Israeli fighter jets roared in the skies, swooping low to unleash bombs on residential buildings and homes. International aid organizations called upon the global community to intervene, labeling the situation a potential war crime involving forced population transfers.

Amid inadequate resources and shortages, Palestinian medical professionals felt constrained to remain in their posts. Mohammad Abu Selim, the general director of Shifa, Gaza’s largest hospital, declared evacuation an impossibility. Despite deteriorating conditions—scarce electricity due to the Israeli blockade, an overwhelmed hospital staff, and a packed morgue—Abu Selim stated that no alternative safe location existed in Gaza to accommodate 600 patients, many critically injured.

“The idea of evacuation is not just absurd; it’s unfeasible,” Abu Selim noted.

Meanwhile, other Palestinians across the region grappled with the devastating decision as the intensity of Israeli retaliatory actions escalated. While the Israeli military claims their airstrikes are aimed at militant infrastructure and not at civilians, many Palestinians dispute this assertion.

Numerous residents hastily traveled south, navigating through debris-filled roads amidst roaring explosions. A chaotic procession of various forms of transport extended for nearly 30 kilometers (around 18 miles) across the territory. What usually takes 45 minutes transformed into a life-threatening, two-hour ordeal. According to the Hamas press office, Israeli airstrikes on evacuating vehicles resulted in at least 70 fatalities.

“For me, trust in the Israeli military is non-existent,” remarked Ali Abdul Bari, a 37-year-old Gaza City resident. “Nonetheless, my primary duty is to ensure the safety of my family.”

After an airstrike obliterated Bari’s apartment, he managed to reach Khan Younis, a southern Gaza city, albeit without all his family members. Bari expressed a resolve to return for the relatives he left behind, emphasizing his familial obligations.

Despite the persistent threats, some chose to stay put, recalling past waves of Palestinian refugees displaced by earlier conflicts, never to return home. Others lacked the resources or the advanced planning needed to evacuate.

In the Jabaliya camp, Jamal was immobilized by the absence of a vehicle and the daunting prospect of evacuating his large family through perilous conditions. Resigned, he said he would leave his fate to divine will.

Communication of evacuation orders was further hampered by collapsing mobile phone networks and internet services in large parts of Gaza.

In Gaza City’s core, now devastated by sustained bombardment, 27-year-old engineer Saeb al-Jarz waited for news of his injured father following a recent airstrike that destroyed their residential tower and killed three neighbors. Initially inclined to stay, al-Jarz’s resolve wavered as he pondered the safety of his 25 relatives.

“Perhaps we should stay; if we die, at least we die together,” he reflected, his voice tinged with fear. Yet, as he pondered the situation, he revised his stance.

“All I desire is to continue living,” he concluded.

Reported by DeBre from Jerusalem.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Gaza Dilemma

What is the main dilemma faced by residents of Gaza as described in the article?

The main dilemma faced by residents of Gaza is whether to heed the Israeli military’s evacuation orders and risk displacement to an uncertain and potentially unsafe location in southern Gaza, or to stay in their current residences, which have been declared as target zones for airstrikes. This presents an existential crisis for many, with no clear or safe options available.

What prompted the Israeli military to issue an evacuation ultimatum?

The Israeli military issued an evacuation ultimatum on the sixth day of aerial bombardments, which were initiated in response to a brutal attack by Hamas that resulted in the deaths of over 1,300 Israelis. The military gave residents of northern Gaza and Gaza City 24 hours to make a decision.

How are hospitals and healthcare workers affected by the situation?

Hospitals like Shifa, the largest in Gaza, are inadequately supplied and understaffed. Despite being overwhelmed with patients and facing dwindling electricity supplies, medical professionals feel they have no option but to stay because there are no other safe locations to which they can move their patients. The general director of Shifa described the idea of evacuation as “unfeasible.”

How have Palestinians responded to the Israeli army’s claim that airstrikes are targeting militant infrastructure and not civilians?

Many Palestinians dispute the Israeli army’s assertion that airstrikes are solely aimed at militant infrastructure. They argue that residential areas and civilian infrastructure are also being targeted, which is evident in the widespread devastation and casualties.

What obstacles are faced by Palestinians choosing to evacuate?

Those choosing to evacuate face multiple challenges including a lack of transportation, blocked and rubble-filled roads, and the ongoing risk of airstrikes even as they attempt to leave. Communication is also an issue due to the collapse of mobile phone networks and internet services in many parts of Gaza.

What are some of the reasons some residents choose not to evacuate?

Some residents choose not to evacuate due to past experiences of displacement from which they were never able to return home. Others simply do not have the means to evacuate, or they decide that if they are to face danger, they prefer to do so in the solidarity of their community and family.

Who reported the article and from where?

The article was reported by DeBre, who is based in Jerusalem.

More about Gaza Dilemma

  • Israeli Military’s Evacuation Ultimatum
  • Overview of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict
  • Status of Hospitals in Gaza
  • International Laws on Forced Population Transfers
  • Hamas’ Role in the Current Conflict
  • Civilian Impact of Aerial Bombardments in Gaza
  • Historical Context: Palestinian Displacement

You may also like


JohnDoe October 14, 2023 - 6:00 am

Wow, this is heartbreaking. People having to decide between two dangerous options… can’t even imagine.

BethM October 14, 2023 - 9:14 am

i can’t believe hospitals have no other option but to stay put. That’s insane!

AnnaL October 14, 2023 - 10:36 am

Where are the human rights when you need them? Seems like it’s just words and no action.

SamK October 14, 2023 - 11:15 am

This is an eye-opener. We often forget how complex and nuanced these situations can be. There’s no easy solution here.

Mike87 October 14, 2023 - 11:55 am

Why isn’t the international community doing anything about this? It’s clearly a dire situation.

TerryS October 14, 2023 - 2:22 pm

Reading this makes me think how lucky most of us are. We don’t have to make such life or death decisions every day.

KevinH October 14, 2023 - 3:20 pm

Is peace so hard to achieve? Humanity needs to do better.

SarahWilliams October 14, 2023 - 4:54 pm

so much pain and suffering… it’s like they can’t catch a break.

LindaG October 14, 2023 - 9:37 pm

If they’re targeting militants, then why are so many civilians being affected? Something doesn’t add up here.


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News