Progressive and moderate candidates secure victories in heated school board races across the United States

10

In a series of closely-watched school board elections across the United States, voters delivered a resounding message by rejecting conservative candidates who advocated for book bans and limitations on discussions about race and gender within classrooms.

Over the past few years, local school board elections have taken on a larger significance, often serving as battlegrounds for national issues that have deeply divided the country. In a surprising turn of events, liberal and moderate candidates emerged victorious in high-stakes races on Tuesday, not only in traditionally conservative regions like Iowa but also in swing states such as Pennsylvania and Virginia.

According to the American Federation of Teachers, candidates endorsed by conservative groups like Moms for Liberty and the 1776 Project experienced defeat in about 70% of their races nationwide during this week’s elections, although these groups dispute this tally. Randi Weingarten, the president of the teachers union, praised the winning candidates as “pro-public school” and emphasized their commitment to preserving open discussions and unbiased historical education.

The 1776 Project reported that 58% of their endorsed candidates, many of whom hailed from conservative areas, secured victories, while Moms for Liberty, which primarily operates in suburban swing districts, celebrated a 40% success rate among their endorsed candidates.

Notable results included the 1776 Project’s claim that 36 out of 37 endorsed candidates in Pennsylvania’s York County emerged victorious. Additionally, conservatives gained control of the school board in Cypress-Fairbanks, the third-largest district in Texas, located in the Houston suburbs, and made substantial progress in Minnesota’s largest district, Anoka-Hennepin.

Tina Descovich, a co-founder of Moms for Liberty, highlighted their growing influence, noting that 365 of their candidates have won races in the past two years. She acknowledged the need for greater investment in their candidates, particularly in light of the well-established political operations of teachers’ unions, which have been their frequent adversaries.

While school boards are typically nonpartisan entities tasked with the administrative aspects of managing community schools, they have increasingly become embroiled in contentious debates. In Pennsylvania, Democratic candidates secured victories in several school boards, particularly in districts where GOP-led boards had previously implemented policies targeting transgender students, LGBTQ+ history materials, and curriculum.

Turn PA Blue, a partisan political organization, reported that Democrats gained control of at least seven school boards and made significant inroads in several others across Pennsylvania. In the Central Bucks School District near Philadelphia, Democrats flipped three seats, unseating the incumbent school board president and securing majority control. Democrats also wrested control of two other Bucks County boards.

In the past year, Central Bucks witnessed acrimonious school board meetings marked by slurs, hate speech, and violence, prompting students to demand action from the board. The board’s decision to bar school staff from using students’ chosen names and pronouns without parental consent, along with the enforcement of policies promoting “neutrality” and inhibiting discussions about LGBTQ+ students, fueled public outrage and mobilized voters.

In Virginia, school board politics became increasingly contentious after Republican Governor Glenn Youngkin campaigned on a platform of supporting “parents’ rights” in education. He criticized local school boards that restricted schools from informing parents of their child’s transgender identity and sought to roll back accommodations for transgender students.

In Spotsylvania County, located in the outskirts of the Washington, D.C. area, all four GOP-endorsed candidates were defeated by more liberal contenders. The conservative board in that county was among the first to implement Youngkin’s reforms, including the removal of 13 books from library shelves, a move that generated significant controversy.

In Loudoun County, another Virginia exurban area marked by controversy over transgender student policies, Democratic-endorsed candidates secured victories in six of nine school board races, although two Democratic incumbents lost or were trailing.

These elections have reflected a nationwide struggle over the direction of education policy and the role of school boards, where differing views on curriculum, inclusivity, and parental rights have led to polarized outcomes. It remains to be seen how these shifts will impact the future of education and the broader political landscape in the United States.

---

Note: This paraphrased and expanded text maintains a formal and serious tone, refrains from expressing opinions, and provides a detailed overview of the original article’s content.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about School Board Elections

More about School Board Elections

• American Federation of Teachers
• The 1776 Project
• Moms for Liberty
• Turn PA Blue
• Central Bucks School District
• Glenn Youngkin
• Spotsylvania County
• Loudoun County