Limited Support from Allies for Canada Following Allegations of Indian Involvement in Citizen’s Death

by Andrew Wright
0 comment
Canada-India Relations

When Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau claimed in a parliamentary session that India might be implicated in the murder of a Canadian national, the understated reaction from the international community served as a poignant lesson in contemporary geopolitics.

The apparent reluctance of Canada’s key allies—including the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, and New Zealand, who are closely aligned in the “Five Eyes” intelligence consortium—to amplify Trudeau’s accusations sheds light on India’s emerging role as an indispensible global player.

Context of the India-Canada Strain

The deceased, Hardeep Singh Nijjar, was a Sikh activist whose assassination has intensified the rift between Canada and India. While these nations have expressed their concerns and have called for thorough investigations, none have openly censured India for its purported role in the June murder, which occurred in Canada.

Geopolitical Calculations

One primary reason for this restraint is the collective need to strengthen relations with India as a strategic counterbalance to China’s growing influence and assertiveness. However, the rationale extends beyond geopolitics. India’s rapid economic expansion is projected to make it the world’s third-largest economy by 2030, surpassing both Japan and Germany. Additionally, with a population exceeding 1.4 billion and one of the largest military forces globally, India has emerged as a formidable presence on the international stage.

Repercussions for Allies

This places Canada’s primary allies, who are also significant partners for India, in a challenging position when it comes to vocally expressing criticism. Experts like Janice Stein from the Munk School of Global Affairs in Toronto and Sushant Singh from the Centre for Policy Research in New Delhi concur that the West’s reliance on India for counterbalancing China makes it more likely to adopt a policy of non-interference.

Diplomatic Undertones

After leveling “credible allegations” regarding India’s involvement in the assassination, which took place near Vancouver, Trudeau subsequently toned down his statements. This change in tone occurred following India’s escalation of tensions through the expulsion of a top Canadian diplomat. The British government has been particularly circumspect due to ongoing trade negotiations with India, clarifying that the issue would not be part of trade discussions.

Muted Response from the White House

Although U.S. officials have denied declining to support Canada’s position, the American response seems more focused on moral support rather than concrete actions, reflecting the United States’ broader strategic interests in maintaining a healthy relationship with India.


If Trudeau’s allegations are substantiated, it could imply that the government led by Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi is not guided by a strict adherence to rule of law or democratic principles. Such a style of governance draws comparisons with other international leaders like Russian President Vladimir Putin, known for targeted killings of opponents both domestically and abroad.

Canada’s Diplomatic Stance

Canada has a history of vocalizing its commitment to human rights and international law, even when it means clashing with major global powers. Previous diplomatic spats with countries like China and Saudi Arabia exemplify Canada’s willingness to stand its ground, but the restrained international response to its latest allegations raises questions about who, if anyone, will offer Canada unequivocal support in the current predicament.

In sum, the case underscores the complexities of modern diplomacy, where geopolitical considerations and strategic alliances often take precedence over moral imperatives. The situation remains fluid, and it is yet to be seen how these unfolding dynamics will influence Canada’s international standing.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Canada-India Relations

What led to the strained Canada-India relations mentioned in the text?

The strain in Canada-India relations stemmed from Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s assertion in Parliament that India might have been involved in the murder of a Canadian citizen, Hardeep Singh Nijjar. This allegation raised tensions between the two nations.

Why did Canada’s key allies not echo Trudeau’s allegations against India?

Canada’s main allies, including the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, and New Zealand, did not openly condemn India for its alleged involvement in the murder. This reluctance is due to several factors. Firstly, these nations are keen to bolster their ties with India as a counterweight to China’s rising influence and power. Secondly, India’s robust economic growth, substantial population, and large military presence make it a significant global player. Thus, these geopolitical considerations play a pivotal role in their response.

What are the implications of India’s growing economic and geopolitical influence?

India’s rapid economic expansion, with projections of becoming the world’s third-largest economy by 2030, has made it a major player in global affairs. Its substantial population and military capabilities further enhance its significance on the international stage. This growing influence has made it challenging for Canada’s primary allies to openly criticize India, given their mutual interests and strategic partnerships.

How did the international community react to Canada’s allegations against India?

The international community, including the United States, refrained from openly condemning India in response to Canada’s allegations. Instead, they expressed concerns and called for thorough investigations. This measured response reflects the delicate balance between their strategic interests, such as countering China, and the need to maintain relations with India.

What are the potential diplomatic repercussions of Canada’s accusations against India?

The diplomatic repercussions of Canada’s accusations against India are multifaceted. They may strain bilateral relations and complicate ongoing trade negotiations, such as the case with the United Kingdom. Additionally, the response from Canada’s allies may impact the country’s standing in international diplomacy, highlighting the complexities of modern diplomacy where geopolitical considerations often take precedence over moral imperatives.

More about Canada-India Relations

You may also like

Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News