Judge rules white man will stand trial for shooting Black teen Ralph Yarl, who went to wrong house

by Ryan Lee
Controversial Shooting Case

A Missouri judge has ruled that the 84-year-old white homeowner, Andrew Lester, who shot a Black teenager, Ralph Yarl, after Yarl mistakenly entered Lester’s residence, must stand trial. The decision was made by Clay County Judge Louis Angles following a preliminary hearing during which several witnesses, including Ralph Yarl himself, provided testimony. The incident occurred on April 13 when Yarl went to the wrong house to pick up his younger brothers.

Andrew Lester, a retired aircraft mechanic, is facing charges of first-degree assault and armed criminal action. He had previously pleaded not guilty to the shooting, which garnered significant attention due to its implications on gun policies and racial dynamics in America. Lester’s next court appearance is scheduled for an arraignment on September 20.

During the hearing, Ralph Yarl testified that he was tasked with collecting his twin siblings but did not have his phone as he had lost it at school. Despite intending to go to a house just a few blocks from his own, Yarl mistakenly arrived at the wrong address. He described ringing the doorbell and feeling that the wait for someone to respond was longer than usual.

Upon the door’s opening, Yarl reached out towards the storm door, assuming he was meeting his brother’s friends’ parents. However, it was Lester who confronted Yarl, instructing him never to return. Yarl recounted being shot in the head and subsequently in the arm. Lester’s defense attorney, Steve Salmon, argued that Lester acted in self-defense, explaining that the elderly man was frightened by the unexpected visitor at his door while he was preparing for bed.

Salmon emphasized Lester’s age and physical vulnerability, asserting that he was unable to protect himself adequately. He characterized the shooting as a tragic event but not a criminal one. District Attorney Zachary Thompson countered this by highlighting that while Missouri law offers provisions for self-defense, it does not grant the right to shoot an unarmed individual, particularly a young teenager, through a door.

Lester’s concerns about his actions were evident in statements provided by law enforcement officers who responded to the scene. Kansas City Officer Larry Dunaway described Lester as a scared elderly individual, while another officer, James Gale, confirmed Lester’s worry and his hope that he had not caused a fatality.

Support for Ralph Yarl has been palpable, as indicated by the presence of individuals in the courtroom wearing shirts bearing the words “Justice for Ralph.” Others wore shirts stating, “Ringing a doorbell is not a crime.” Yarl is still recuperating from the traumatic brain injury he sustained during the incident. Despite this, he managed to complete an engineering internship over the summer and has commenced his senior year of high school. He plans to pursue engineering in college.

The incident stemmed from Yarl’s unintended presence at Lester’s house, as he was supposed to pick up his younger brothers from a neighboring location. Lester’s claim was that he shot Yarl out of fear that he was about to be robbed. While Missouri has “stand your ground” laws that allow individuals to use force when threatened, the legal proceedings will delve into whether Lester’s actions truly constituted self-defense.

Amidst the legal proceedings, the case has triggered discussions about gun policies, self-defense, and racial dynamics. The trial will further explore these aspects, aiming to establish the appropriate legal outcome in a case that has raised important questions about individual rights and societal responsibilities.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Mistaken Identity Shooting

What is the case about?

The case revolves around a white homeowner shooting a Black teenager who mistakenly entered his house, prompting legal proceedings.

Who is the homeowner involved?

The homeowner is Andrew Lester, an 84-year-old retired aircraft mechanic.

Why did Lester shoot the teenager?

Lester claims he shot the teenager, Ralph Yarl, out of fear that he was about to be robbed due to mistaken identity.

What charges does Lester face?

Lester is charged with first-degree assault and armed criminal action.

What happened during the preliminary hearing?

During the preliminary hearing, witnesses, including Ralph Yarl, provided testimony about the incident.

What is the focus of the trial?

The trial will focus on aspects like racial dynamics, self-defense claims, and gun policies.

How did Yarl end up at Lester’s house?

Ralph Yarl was sent to pick up his younger brothers but mistakenly entered the wrong house due to confusion.

What is Lester’s defense?

Lester’s defense attorney argues that he acted in self-defense, given his age and fear of the unexpected visitor.

What is the next court date?

Lester’s arraignment is scheduled for September 20.

What discussions has the case sparked?

The case has sparked discussions about gun policies, self-defense rights, and racial tensions in society.

More about Mistaken Identity Shooting

You may also like


Jake92 August 31, 2023 - 9:33 pm

man, dis case be messin’ wif mah head. like, shootin’ a teen coz he came 2 da wrong crib? ain’t right, ya kno?

RileyW August 31, 2023 - 10:10 pm

wait, ain’t dis da land of freedom? y da fuss ’bout gun rights but no talk ’bout teen’s right 2 live?

AutoLover September 1, 2023 - 2:45 am

lemme get dis straight, he’s 84? and couldn’t ID a teen? sounds fishy, old man.


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News