Homicides are rising in the nation’s capital, but police are solving far fewer of the cases

19

Homicide rates in the nation’s capital have been steadily increasing, raising concerns as police struggle to solve a significant number of these cases. While Washington, D.C., may no longer hold the title of the homicide capital of the United States, it is currently experiencing a multiyear surge in homicides, with a troubling decline in the rate at which these cases are being solved.

For the families of the victims, the impact of unsolved homicides is profound and distressing. Asiyah Timimi, whose husband, Aqueel, tragically lost his life in a dispute in January 2021, expressed the pervasive sense of insecurity that prevails when perpetrators remain at large. She stated, “You just don’t feel safe until they’re caught,” adding that she could potentially cross paths with her husband’s killer.

Similarly, Natalia Mitchell seeks justice for her son Morris, who was fatally shot in March 2022. She believes that a successful arrest in her son’s case would not bring Morris back, but it would provide a measure of closure.

However, the Metropolitan Police Department’s (MPD) ability to solve these homicides has seen a sharp decline in 2023, leading the city on a path to record its lowest “clearance rate” or “closure rate” in over 15 years. As of November 13th, only 75 out of 244 homicides committed this year have been solved by the police. When considering the 33 prior-year homicides cleared in 2023, the overall closure rate stands at approximately 45%. This rate is notably lower than the national average, which typically hovers between 50% and 60%, according to Rick Rosenfeld, a criminology professor.

A low clearance rate, particularly in homicide cases, has far-reaching consequences. It can undermine police morale, erode trust between the community and law enforcement, and hinder public cooperation, which is essential for effective investigations. Christopher Herrmann, an associate professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice and a former crime analyst supervisor with the New York Police Department, highlighted this concerning trend.

Deputy Mayor for Public Safety Lyndsey Appiah acknowledged the importance of closure in providing some semblance of justice for the victims and emphasized the deterrent effect that swift and successful investigations can have on crime rates.

The drop in homicide closures is just one facet of a broader public safety crisis in the nation’s capital. Appiah cited police staffing issues and challenges in crime scene analysis as potential factors affecting the clearance rate. The MPD’s officer count has decreased from 3,800 in 2020 to around 3,300 this year, a decline attributed by police union officials to what they consider anti-police policies by the D.C. Council. In addition, the city’s crime lab, the Department of Forensic Science, lost its accreditation in 2021, leading to outsourcing of crime scene analysis, a process that consumes both time and resources.

Appiah cautioned against premature judgments, as homicide investigations often span months or even years. However, with only a few weeks left in the year, it would require a remarkable surge in successful arrests to prevent 2023 from registering the lowest homicide clearance rate in over a decade.

The consequences of unsolved homicides are extensive, affecting both families and the police force. It leaves families grappling with a sense of injustice and the absence of closure. For the police, it can lead to a breakdown of trust within the community, hindering their ability to effectively combat violent crime.

Efforts to address this issue involve encouraging residents to come forward with information, thereby aiding in the apprehension of violent criminals. Trust between the community and the police is vital in this endeavor, as Deputy Mayor Appiah emphasized. The hope is that with increased cooperation and accountability, the city can work towards making its streets safer.

As Washington, D.C., grapples with rising homicide rates and the challenge of solving these crimes, the importance of closure and community involvement cannot be overstated. For those affected by these unsolved killings, it is not just about justice; it is about healing and preventing further tragedy.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Crisis in Homicide Solvability

More about Crisis in Homicide Solvability

• Rising Homicides in Washington, D.C.
• Declining Homicide Clearance Rates
• Consequences of Low Clearance Rates
• Factors Impacting Clearance Rates
• Community Cooperation in Solving Crimes
• Broader Public Safety Concerns
• Efforts to Improve Homicide Solvability