French Shooting Reveals Global Struggle Against Racism and Police Brutality

A disturbing incident of police violence captured on video, followed by protests and riots fueled by longstanding tensions regarding law enforcement’s treatment of minorities. Calls for accountability echo in France after the tragic shooting of a 17-year-old by police in a Paris suburb, drawing comparisons to the racial reckoning experienced in the United States following the deaths of George Floyd and other people of color at the hands of law enforcement.

Despite the cultural, institutional, and community differences between the two nations, the shooting in France and the subsequent outcry highlight that the United States is not alone in grappling with the pervasive issues of systemic racism and police brutality.

In other news, more than 900 people were arrested overnight as young rioters clashed with police across France. Authorities reported that the assailant who attacked a Muslim lawmaker had initially made lewd comments and attempted to kiss her. Additionally, there have been clashes between French police and youths, as well as looting, during the fourth night of riots triggered by the fatal police shooting.

Tracy Ladji, an activist with SOS Racisme, expressed, “These incidents occur when you are French but have foreign roots. We are not considered French, and our skin color and origins are the sole focus, regardless of being born in France. Racism within the police force claims lives, and far too many officers embrace far-right ideologies. This must come to an end.”

An editorial published by the French newspaper Le Monde drew parallels between the recent events and the 2020 killing of George Floyd by a white Minneapolis police officer, which sparked months of unrest both in the United States and internationally, including protests in Paris. The editorial noted, “This act was committed by a law enforcement officer, filmed, and broadcast almost in real time, involving a representative of a socially discriminated category.”

The teenager, identified only as Nahel, was shot during a traffic stop in Nanterre, a suburb of Paris. Video footage showed two officers at the car window, with one aiming his gun at the driver. As the teenager began to drive forward, the officer fired a single shot through the windshield.

Speaking to Algerian television Ennahar TV, Nahel’s grandmother, whose name was not disclosed, mentioned that their family has roots in Algeria.

The officer accused of pulling the trigger is facing preliminary charges of voluntary homicide. However, these charges have done little to quell the riots, which have spread across the country and resulted in hundreds of arrests. According to a prosecutor, the officer claimed that he feared for his and his colleague’s safety, as well as the possibility of the car striking them or others, as Nahel attempted to flee.

The officer’s race has not been disclosed by officials. His lawyer stated that he acted based on what he believed was necessary in the moment. During an interview on French TV channel BFMTV, the lawyer mentioned that the officer is devastated, emphasizing that “he truly did not intend to cause death.”

Nahel’s mother, identified only as Mounia M., expressed her anger toward the specific officer who took her child’s life, rather than harboring general resentment towards the police. She stated, “He saw a little kid who looked Arab. He wanted to end his life.”

Although police shootings in France are considerably less frequent than in the United States, they have been on the rise since 2017. Some experts associate this increase with a law that relaxed restrictions on the use of lethal force by officers in response to a series of terrorist attacks involving vehicles.

French police are authorized to open fire at a vehicle when the driver fails to comply with orders and their actions pose a threat to the officers’ lives or the lives of others. The French police have often faced criticism for their use of violent tactics.

Critics argue that the doctrine of equality among citizens in France has, in reality, concealed generations of systemic racism. Paul Hirschfield, director of the criminal justice program at Rutgers University, described France as a country with long-standing and pervasive issues of police racism, brutality, and impunity, comparing it to the United States.

The video evidence of the shooting, which contradicted initial police statements suggesting that the teenager was driving toward the officer, compelled leaders to swiftly denounce the killing. Even before charges were filed against the officer, French President Emmanuel Macron labeled the shooting as “inexcusable.”

This rapid response by French leaders is not unfamiliar to Americans, who have frequently witnessed similar videos of violent police encounters that often contradicted initial police accounts, well before the gut-wrenching footage of George Floyd’s death beneath a Minneapolis police officer’s knee emerged.

While police training in France lasts approximately ten months, longer than in many U.S. cities, it remains one of the shortest training periods in Europe. However, experts believe that French police do not receive training equivalent to the implicit bias training mandated for many U.S. police officers as part of efforts to improve policing in diverse communities. Nonetheless, the effectiveness of such training has been questioned by critics in the United States.

France, like other European countries, has a growing population of individuals with African, Arab, and Asian backgrounds.

Stacie Keesee, co-founder of the Center for Policing Equity and a member of the United Nations’ International Expert Mechanism to Advance Racial Justice and Equality in Law Enforcement, highlighted the challenges faced by countries with colonial pasts. She stated, “If a country carries the stigma of its colonial history, it becomes painful to engage in conversations about race. Consequently, relevant training for officers is unlikely to be prioritized.”

Bertrand Cavallier, former commander of France’s national gendarmerie training school, emphasized that the actions of one officer should not define the entire law enforcement system. He remarked, “This incident involves a police officer who made a mistake that could have been avoided. However, he was arrested, which sends a clear message about the government’s intentions.”

Note: Some minor details and phrases have been adjusted to provide a concise and coherent rewriting of the text.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Police Brutality

More about Police Brutality

• France shooting: Police killing of 17-year-old sparks protests and riots
• France shaken by police violence and racism after youth’s death
• France’s colonial past and police racism: Explained
• French police brutality against minorities: How does it compare to US?
• France’s colonial history influences policing today