Film Analysis: ‘May December’ – A Tapestry of Emotional Depth and Cinematic Brilliance

“May December” stands out as a daringly self-conscious, humorously sharp, and emotionally intricate drama, challenging conventional genre definitions.

Director Todd Haynes, collaborating with scriptwriter Samy Burch, ingeniously blends over-the-top melodramatic elements with the profound emotional insight reminiscent of Ingmar Bergman’s works, creating a uniquely captivating film that keeps the audience in a state of uncertainty.

The plot centers around actress Elizabeth Barry, portrayed by Natalie Portman, immersing herself in the life of her upcoming film’s subject, Gracie Atherton-Yoo (played by Julianne Moore). The story recounts Gracie’s controversial past, involving her imprisonment at 36 for initiating a relationship with a 12-year-old boy. Fast forward twenty years, she and the boy, Joe (Charles Melton), are now married with three children, navigating their unconventional life.

The film offers brief insights into previous sensationalist adaptations of their story. In their initial interaction, Gracie desires an authentic portrayal from Elizabeth, who in turn seeks to truly understand and represent Gracie’s experiences. Both Moore and Portman deliver these interactions with a blend of polite cordiality and underlying tension, raising questions about trust and perception within the narrative.

Haynes, already acclaimed for his mastery in melodramatic storytelling as seen in “Carol” and “Far From Heaven,” here nods to the sensationalism of tabloid stories, enriching it with a dramatic soundtrack featuring Michel Legrand’s compositions. This is used to great effect, juxtaposing serious and humorous moments, such as a scene where Gracie humorously remarks on a mundane household concern against a dramatically intense musical backdrop.

Portman’s Elizabeth is portrayed as a fiercely determined character, almost resembling an investigative journalist, seeking deeper truths about Gracie’s life. Her portrayal skillfully captures the manipulative aspects of her celebrity status, creating a captivating and unsettling representation of fame and the actor’s craft. This culminates in a scene where the distinction between storytelling and real life is poignantly highlighted.

The film’s brilliance also lies in the dynamic between Moore and Portman, where their on-screen chemistry manifests in subtly aggressive and power-laden exchanges. The true revelation, however, is Charles Melton’s portrayal of Joe. His nuanced performance captures the complex emotional journey of his character, delivering a heart-wrenching depiction without resorting to melodramatic clichés.

Joe, as played by Melton, is portrayed as a subdued figure, navigating his complex relationship with Gracie and his own identity as a father and husband. His portrayal adds a vital layer of depth to the film, shifting it from merely a sensational tale to a profound exploration of character and consequence.

“May December,” released by Netflix for theatrical viewing and streaming, offers a rich narrative tapestry that transcends mere scandal and entertainment, imbuing the film with a soulful depth. Rated R for its mature content and running for 117 minutes, it earns a distinguished three and a half stars out of four.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about May December Review

More about May December Review

• Todd Haynes’ Filmography
• Natalie Portman’s Acting Career
• Julianne Moore’s Notable Roles
• Analysis of Melodrama in Cinema
• Psychological Depth in Films
• The Evolution of Scriptwriting
• Movie Ratings and Their Impact
• Understanding Film Genres