Efforts to Sustain Traditional Methods of Crafting Rich Red Dye Persist in Central Mexico

by Andrew Wright
Cochineal Dye

A family located in the heartland of Mexico is steadfastly committed to the conservation of cochineal dye production, a vibrant, organic red pigment that, in terms of significance, followed only gold and silver as the most valuable resources discovered by the Spanish in Mexico post their 1521 invasion.

Historically, red and purple garments were emblematic of affluence and authority due to their scarcity and high cost. The indigenous method of extracting this pigment from insects provided the Spanish empire with an alternative source of the coveted red dye.

Cities of great historical and architectural value in Mexico, such as Oaxaca, owe much of their prosperity to the trade in cochineal dye, also referred to as carmine or “grana cochinilla” in Spanish. Esteemed by Spanish aristocrats, this dye was notably used to color the military uniforms of the British Empire’s Redcoats, until the advent of synthetic dyes in the 19th century.

The traditional method of acquiring this pigment is time-consuming, laborious, and meticulous. It is sourced from the crushed carcasses of diminutive female insects that contain carminic acid and subsist on nopal cactus plants.

Each of these insects, identified as Dactylopius coccus, must be cultivated until they reach the larvae stage and then placed on a purposely injured nopal cactus pad. Following this, the insect is left for several months to nourish itself and reach maturity.

Subsequently, each insect must be individually collected by hand, typically using a small brush, then sifted, cleansed, and sun-dried.

This technique for extracting the valuable pigment was initially devised by the Mixtecs of Oaxaca several centuries before the Spanish invasion. The pigment was a status symbol employed by indigenous Mexican nobility to color their garments, and it found widespread use in various art forms, including manuscript writing, ceramic decoration, and mural painting.

Mayeli Garcia and her family manage a greenhouse specializing in this labor-intensive, traditional production process in the village of San Francisco Tepeyacac, to the east of Mexico City. Rows of hundreds of nopal cactus pads are methodically arranged on elevated racks and covered in a white powdery substance, indicative of the insects nourishing themselves while simultaneously secreting a waxy protective layer.

“It requires a waiting period of three to four months for the insects to complete their life cycle, followed by the harvest,” Garcia explains. Constant vigilance over each cactus pad is obligatory. This practice is virtually unchanged from the methods used over the past three centuries to produce the finest red dye.

Synthetic dyes, more cost-effective and abundant, started to replace cochineal dye during the 19th century. Nevertheless, artisans in Oaxaca continued some level of production, particularly for use in traditional clothing and rugs.

Recent studies have indicated potential health risks associated with chemical dyes, especially when used as food colorings or cosmetic additives. Such concerns have rekindled interest in natural alternatives like cochineal dye.

Industrial-scale production remains unfeasible due to the limited quantities available. “We have experimented with automating some steps to lessen the manual labor, even inventing our own machinery,” said Garcia, although she admits their initial efforts were not entirely successful.

Garcia faces challenges in sustaining her livelihood from the approximately 100 kilograms (220 pounds) of cochineal dye she produces annually. She is exploring diversification strategies, including the production of other nopal-derived goods like soaps, creams, and jams. For supplemental income, her family continues to cultivate fresh vegetables.

Reducing the price of the dye is not a viable option, given the laborious nature of its production. “The costs associated with the labor make it prohibitive,” she states.

However, Garcia remains committed to preserving this unique ecological system designed to sustain these tiny insects. “There is a burgeoning movement towards revisiting traditional methods because they are intrinsically healthier,” she observes.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about cochineal dye

What is the primary focus of the article?

The article primarily focuses on a family in central Mexico who are committed to preserving the traditional method of producing cochineal dye, a vibrant red pigment.

Who originally developed the method of creating cochineal dye?

The Mixtecs of Oaxaca initially developed the technique for extracting cochineal dye, centuries before the arrival of the Spanish.

Why was cochineal dye historically important?

Historically, cochineal dye was extremely valuable, second only to gold and silver, among the resources discovered by the Spanish in Mexico. It was used to dye garments and became a symbol of wealth and power.

What challenges does cochineal dye face today?

Today, cochineal dye faces competition from synthetic alternatives, which are cheaper and more abundant. Additionally, the labor-intensive nature of traditional cochineal dye production makes it less economical.

What are the potential health concerns related to synthetic dyes?

Some studies have suggested that synthetic dyes, especially red ones, could have adverse health effects when used in food colorings or cosmetics. This has spurred renewed interest in natural alternatives like cochineal dye.

How is the family in the article attempting to sustain cochineal dye production?

The family manages a greenhouse specializing in the traditional production process, and they are exploring methods to automate some steps. They are also looking into diversifying into other nopal-derived products like soaps and creams.

Is industrial-scale production of cochineal dye possible?

No, the article states that industrial-scale production of cochineal dye is not feasible due to the labor-intensive nature of the traditional method and limited quantities available.

What is the family doing for supplemental income?

For supplemental income, the family continues to grow fresh vegetables.

Is the family successful in fully automating the production process?

No, while they have attempted to introduce some automation to lessen manual labor, their initial efforts have not been entirely successful.

Why is the family still committed to preserving this traditional method?

The family believes that there is a burgeoning movement towards returning to traditional methods, partly because they are seen as healthier alternatives to synthetic products.

More about cochineal dye

  • History of Cochineal Dye
  • Traditional Dyeing Techniques in Mexico
  • Health Concerns of Synthetic Dyes
  • The Mixtecs and Their Contribution to Textile Arts
  • The Economics of Craftsmanship: Cochineal Production
  • Cultural Significance of Color in History
  • Sustainability in Traditional Practices
  • The Shift from Natural to Synthetic Dyes
  • The Modern Revival of Natural Dyes

You may also like


AlanT September 2, 2023 - 7:27 am

High costs and labor are a killer combo in any industry. But these folks keep going for the sake of art and history. Respect!

SteveK September 2, 2023 - 12:33 pm

Was in Oaxaca a few years back. the textiles there are just something else. Now I know why.

SarahM September 2, 2023 - 12:57 pm

its really something how this family’s tryin to keep traditions alive. Tough but so important.

NinaS September 2, 2023 - 1:15 pm

Who would have thought? A small insect and a cactus can be this significant. Nature’s incredible.

JohnDoe September 2, 2023 - 2:20 pm

Wow, never knew red dye had such a rich history. Makes you think twice about what we wear and where it comes from!

ClaireW September 2, 2023 - 4:17 pm

Found this eye-opening. Makes me wanna dive into the history of dyes and colors. Anyone got book recs?

MikeR September 2, 2023 - 7:24 pm

Synthetic dyes replacing natural ones, typical story. But health issues? gotta look into that more.

EmilyH September 2, 2023 - 10:18 pm

i love how this goes beyond just dye. It’s also about preserving culture and history, you know? Hats off to that family.

TomL September 3, 2023 - 1:21 am

I’m all for going back to natural ways, especially if it’s healthier. Kudos to this family for taking the lead.


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News