Assessment: Shifting Conference Dynamics in College Sports: Advantages Still Unclear

The dominant structure of the Power Five has now contracted into what can be termed as a “Super Four” within the realm of collegiate athletics.

Once a significant player, the Pac-12 found itself dissected, its valuable components redistributed among rival conferences in a pursuit of financial enhancement.

This transition raises questions for the immediate future.

California Athletic Director Jim Knowlton emphasized this point when he stated, “The ramifications of these pivotal decisions over the last two years will likely become fully apparent half a decade from now,” shortly after the University of California joined the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) out of necessity.

Beginning the following year, institutions like the University of California and Stanford, along with Southern Methodist University in Dallas, will be part of an 18-member conference. For football, the count will be 17, given that Notre Dame maintains its independence. Until this recent development, the ACC had no schools situated west of the Mississippi.

The ACC has now aligned itself with the Big Ten, Big 12, and SEC to become the titans of college sports. By August 2024, all will consist of at least 16 member schools.

Arriving late to exploit the remnants of the dismantled Pac-12, the ACC finds itself in the league of these major conferences. Jim Phillips, ACC Commissioner, observed, “The landscape has transitioned from region-specific affiliations to national, covering coast to coast. Such radical change is pushing all of us involved in collegiate athletics to adapt or risk obsolescence.”

This seismic shift commenced in 2021 when Texas and Oklahoma announced their departure from the Big 12 to join the Southeastern Conference (SEC). Though the move had geographical logic, it essentially concentrated wealth and sent ripple effects across the sector.

In response, the Big Ten expanded westward, acquiring the University of Southern California and UCLA in the summer of 2022. The Big 12, weary of being targeted, turned aggressive and sought to dismantle the Pac-12 to eliminate potential competition for diminishing TV revenue streams.

For the ACC, plagued by internal discord, expansion serves as a strategy to tackle both immediate and long-term challenges, primarily financial. Even though expansion is beneficial, it failed to win over Florida State in the voting process.

Despite a legal agreement holding ACC members together until 2036, there’s been enough unrest, particularly from Florida State, to raise concerns about a potential fracturing of the conference before the contract expires.

The college sports landscape is also experiencing shifts at the level of the College Football Playoff, which will expand its roster from four to 12 teams in the coming year.

Initially, when the playoff’s expanded format was announced, there was optimism that it could deter further conference realignments. Ironically, the same commissioners responsible for the realignments are now in a position to further consolidate power and wealth among an increasingly smaller set of conferences.

This frenzy, largely fueled by the television industry’s billions, has led to uneasy alliances and decisions that seem to neglect tradition, fans, athletes, and the potential long-term repercussions.

“As we stand at yet another historical inflection point,” remarked Carol Christ, Chancellor at the University of California, “the time will come, probably within five years, when we must assess whether these monumental changes have been for better or worse.”

Follow Ralph D. Russo on Twitter and listen at AP Podcasts

For more on college football, visit BigBigNews College Football and AP Top 25 College Football Poll

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Conference Realignment in College Sports

More about Conference Realignment in College Sports

• Power Five Conferences
• Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC)
• Big Ten Conference
• Big 12 Conference
• Southeastern Conference (SEC)
• NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament
• College Football Playoff Expansion
• Impact of Television Broadcast Deals
• University of California Athletics
• Internal Discord in ACC