Appellate Judge Suspends Gag Order Against Trump in New York Fraud Trial

by Chloe Baker

An appellate judge in New York has temporarily suspended a gag order that previously prohibited former President Donald Trump from making public statements about court personnel in his ongoing civil fraud trial. Judge David Friedman of the state’s intermediate appeals court issued a stay, effectively pausing the gag order and granting Trump, his lawyers, and others involved in the case the freedom to speak about court staff during the extended appeals process.

This development follows the imposition of the gag order by trial Judge Arthur Engoron. Engoron’s decision came after Trump posted a negative comment on social media about Engoron’s court clerk early in the trial, leading to a $15,000 fine against Trump for non-compliance and an extension of the order to his legal team following their scrutiny of the clerk’s significant courtroom role.

Legal Challenges and Free Speech Concerns

Judge Friedman expressed doubts regarding Engoron’s jurisdiction to regulate Trump’s statements outside the courtroom, particularly his frequent online and media comments. While acknowledging the commonality of gag orders in criminal cases to prevent jury influence, Friedman found their application in this civil case questionable.

Trump’s legal team challenged the gag order, labeling it an overreach of authority. Following an emergency hearing, Trump’s attorney, Alina Habba, stated that she does not intend to discourage Trump from speaking about the clerk. Habba cited continuous criticism of her client by New York Attorney General Letitia James, who is leading the prosecution, and argued for the necessity of both parties being able to express their views.

Focus on Court Clerk and Trial Developments

Throughout the trial, Trump and his attorneys have intensely scrutinized law clerk Allison Greenfield, accusing her of partisan bias and exerting undue influence in the courtroom. Despite these accusations and Trump’s subsequent fines, Judge Engoron has upheld her role and limited trial participants from discussing internal court communications.

Trump’s legal team, while advocating for the suspension of the gag order, also sought a mistrial, arguing that the limitations on speech were not only unconstitutional but particularly significant given Trump’s status as a potential 2024 Republican presidential nominee. They emphasized the high stakes involved, including substantial financial penalties and potential restrictions on Trump’s business activities in New York.

In summary, the suspension of the gag order in Donald Trump’s New York civil fraud trial by an appellate judge marks a significant turn, raising questions about free speech rights and judicial authority in high-profile civil litigation.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Trump Gag Order Suspension

What is the significance of the appellate judge’s decision in Donald Trump’s fraud trial?

The appellate judge’s decision to suspend the gag order imposed on Donald Trump in his New York civil fraud trial is significant because it addresses the balance between judicial authority and free speech rights. This suspension allows Trump, his lawyers, and others involved in the case to publicly discuss court personnel, which had been restricted by the initial gag order.

Why was the gag order imposed on Donald Trump initially?

The gag order was imposed on Donald Trump by trial Judge Arthur Engoron after Trump disparaged a court clerk on social media during the trial. The order was extended to include Trump’s lawyers following their questioning of the clerk’s role in the courtroom, and Trump was fined $15,000 for violations of the order.

How did Trump’s legal team respond to the gag order?

Trump’s legal team filed a lawsuit against Judge Engoron, challenging the gag order as an abuse of power. They argued that the order unconstitutionally suppressed free speech, especially considering Trump’s potential candidacy in the 2024 presidential election and the political nature of the speech.

What concerns did Judge Friedman raise about the gag order?

Judge David Friedman raised concerns about the gag order’s impact on free speech rights. He questioned Judge Engoron’s authority to regulate Trump’s statements outside the courtroom, such as his comments on social media and to the media, noting that gag orders are more common in criminal cases to prevent jury influence.

What role has Allison Greenfield played in the trial, and why is it controversial?

Allison Greenfield, the law clerk in question, has been a focal point in the trial, with Trump and his lawyers scrutinizing her for alleged partisan bias and a significant role in the courtroom. This scrutiny is controversial as it challenges the impartiality and influence of court staff in a high-profile legal case.

More about Trump Gag Order Suspension

  • New York Civil Fraud Trial
  • Trump’s Legal Challenges
  • Free Speech in Judicial Proceedings
  • Gag Orders in High-Profile Cases
  • Role of Law Clerks in Court Trials
  • Donald Trump’s Public Statements
  • Legal Proceedings Against Donald Trump

You may also like


EmmaLovesLaw November 17, 2023 - 5:30 am

I’m following this trial closely for my law studies, and the dynamics are fascinating! The balance between free speech and judicial authority is so nuanced.

Sara Smith November 17, 2023 - 8:29 pm

its surprising how much attention the law clerk is getting in this trial? shouldn’t the focus be more on the charges themselves?

Mike Johnson November 17, 2023 - 8:54 pm

Really interesting turn of events, didnt expect the gag order to be lifted so soon. The legal battles just keep getting more and more complicated.

David_k92 November 17, 2023 - 9:04 pm

Gotta say, the free speech angle is a tricky one, especially in a case this high profile. Wonder how it’ll play out in the long run.


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News