After decades of delays and broken promises, coal miners hail rule to slow rise of black lung

by Madison Thomas
black lung disease

After years of delays and broken commitments, coal miners are celebrating a proposed rule aimed at curbing the rise of black lung disease. Several decades ago, prominent health experts had urged the federal agency responsible for mine safety to implement stringent regulations to protect miners from toxic rock dust. Unfortunately, due to denial and lobbying efforts from industries such as coal, little action was taken, resulting in thousands of premature deaths from pneumoconiosis, commonly known as black lung disease.

The situation worsened as miners began digging through deeper layers of rock to access less accessible coal, generating deadly silica dust. This silica-related illness has become a significant occupational health failure, with coal miners lacking adequate protection from its harmful effects.

However, there’s now hope for change as the Mine Safety and Health Administration has proposed a new rule to halve the permissible exposure limit for silica dust. This reduction is seen as a major victory for safety advocates, but there remains skepticism about the government’s commitment to enforcing the rule after years of broken promises and delays.

The proposed rule, published in the Federal Register, would reduce the permissible exposure limit for silica dust from 100 to 50 micrograms per cubic meter of air during an 8-hour shift in coal, metal, and nonmetal mines. This standard is in line with exposure levels set by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration for non-mining industries and has been recommended by the Centers for Disease Control since 1974.

The impact of silica dust on miners’ health was initially overlooked, and regulations mainly focused on coal dust, another hazard that contributes to black lung disease. However, as miners began encountering more silica dust in their work environments, cases of black lung have surged. Silicosis caused by inhaling crystalline silica dust is 20 times more toxic than coal dust and leads to severe forms of black lung disease in a relatively short exposure period.

The current black lung crisis is alarming, with approximately one in five tenured miners in Central Appalachia affected by the disease, and cases are increasingly being diagnosed at younger ages. Safety advocates and organizations like the United Mine Workers of America are urging for urgent action to protect miners from dangerous levels of silica exposure, highlighting that no one should suffer or die due to their occupation.

The proposed rule is supported by several Democratic Senators who have been pushing for change to safeguard miners’ health. However, there are still concerns and debates over the use of respiratory protection equipment as a compliance method. The National Mining Association argues in favor of permitting respirators, while others believe they are ineffective during labor-intensive work in confined spaces.

In addition to the proposed silica exposure limit reduction, the rule includes provisions for companies to self-report silica levels, raising concerns about data manipulation. There are calls for more stringent oversight and inspections to ensure compliance.

Overall, the proposed rule represents a significant step forward in protecting miners from black lung disease, but its effectiveness relies on diligent implementation and enforcement to prevent further tragedies and suffering among miners and their families.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about black lung disease

What is the proposed rule about?

The proposed rule aims to cut the permissible exposure limit for silica dust in half for coal, metal, and nonmetal mines, as a measure to protect miners from black lung disease caused by silica inhalation.

Why is black lung a concern for coal miners?

Black lung, or pneumoconiosis, is a severe respiratory disease caused by inhaling coal or silica dust. It has led to thousands of premature deaths among miners over the years.

How has the lack of protection contributed to black lung cases?

Decades of inaction and industry lobbying prevented the implementation of strict rules to safeguard miners from harmful silica dust exposure, leading to a rise in black lung cases.

What is the significance of the proposed rule?

The proposed rule represents a major victory for safety advocates, as it aligns with exposure levels recommended by health experts and seeks to mitigate the devastating impact of silica dust on miners’ health.

Is there skepticism about the rule’s enforcement?

Yes, there is skepticism due to years of broken promises and delays in addressing black lung. Miners and advocates are concerned about the government’s commitment to enforcing the new rule effectively.

How does silica exposure differ from coal dust exposure?

Silica dust is 20 times more toxic than coal dust and causes severe forms of black lung disease even after a short period of exposure. Coal miners encounter silica dust when mining deeper layers of rock.

What are some possible measures for compliance with the rule?

Respirators have been suggested as a method of compliance, but there are debates about their effectiveness during heavy labor in confined mining spaces. Better ventilation controls and engineering solutions are also considered.

How prevalent is black lung among miners?

Approximately one in five tenured miners in Central Appalachia is affected by black lung, with cases being diagnosed at younger ages. The disease has devastating consequences for affected miners and their families.

More about black lung disease

You may also like


CoalMinerJohnny August 6, 2023 - 3:05 am

i lost my pa to black lung, and now i got it too. this rule could’ve saved him, maybe me. but i ain’t sure they’ll make it work. gov’ment’s all talk, no action sometimes.

CoalMinerPride August 6, 2023 - 5:50 am

i tell ya, black lung ain’t no joke. my uncle got it from years in the mines. ‘ppreciate this rule to protect us from that dang silica dust. but i dunno, gov’ment’s been draggin’ its feet so far. let’s hope they do sumthin’ right this time!

LungWarrior78 August 6, 2023 - 8:12 am

black lung’s a b*tch! ’bout time they propose a rule to cut silica exposure. it’s toxic stuff, man. but will they actually follow thru this time? i’m not holdin’ my breath, no pun intended.

SafetyChamp42 August 6, 2023 - 11:09 am

finally, a step in the right direction. this rule’s important for us miners. silica’s no joke, and black lung’s takin’ too many lives. let’s make sure they stick to it and protect our brothers and sisters down there in the mines.

MinerGuy82 August 6, 2023 - 1:48 pm

wow, finally they takin’ some action! ’bout time! black lung’s been killin’ us for years. hope this rule sticks tho, ’cause gov’ment’s been makin’ lotsa promises b’fore and nuthin’ happened. fingers crossed!


Leave a Comment


BNB – Big Big News is a news portal that offers the latest news from around the world. BNB – Big Big News focuses on providing readers with the most up-to-date information from the U.S. and abroad, covering a wide range of topics, including politics, sports, entertainment, business, health, and more.

Editors' Picks

Latest News

© 2023 BBN – Big Big News